Jnews is about news!

What investors, analysts say about Ramaphosa game farm scandal report

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa is considering quitting after an advisory panel found the “cash-in-sofa” scandal that’s embroiling his administration may be grounds for his impeachment.

The panel, led by a former chief justice, found the president may have violated sections of the constitution following the theft of $580 000 stashed in a sofa at a game farm owned by Ramaphosa.

Read: Ramaphosa weighs resigning over panel’s farm-scandal report

The ANC’s National Executive Committee is due to discuss the findings and Ramaphosa spent much of Thursday in consultations over the report.

Investors awaiting answers have been selling South African assets amid fears that his potential departure may set back reforms aimed at bolstering economic growth, stabilising public finances and tackling graft.

The dollar-rand cross jumped by as much as 4.4% to 17.95, its biggest increase since March 2020, when South Africa shuttered all but essential services during its first Covid-19 lockdown.

However, the rand gained some lost ground, to trade around R17.59 to the greenback on Thursday evening.

Read:
Rand falls on Ramaphosa crisis
Ramaphosa theft case wounds ANC, threatens economy
President in peril as panel sees case for impeachment

The yield on 10-year rand-denominated debt surged 91 basis points to 11.71%, the most in a day since former President Jacob Zuma’s axing of Nhlanhla Nene as finance minister in December 2015 roiled markets.

Here’s what investors, analysts and business bodies are saying:

Cristian Maggio, head of portfolio and ESG Strategy at TD Securities:

“The market is reacting negatively, but if Cyril Ramaphosa’s position is so compromised that he’s looking to resign, it shouldn’t be too bad for South African assets.

“The market dreads political instability and often prefers to go with the devil they know than the devil they don’t.

“Ramaphosa’s reform agenda has been underwhelming to say the least. Doubts will remain as to whether another ANC candidate can kick start that process, but we surely know that Cyril Ramaphosa is unlikely to deliver what is needed.”

Andrew Matheny and Bojosi Morule of Goldman Sachs Group:

“This is happening at a time when South Africa’s been in a better place fiscally in recent years, but I think the market doesn’t fully buy into the durability of this better fiscal story.

“The main objection people raise is that well, elections are on the horizon in a year and a half and the news of the last 24 hours could translate into increased spending pressures, if the president is replaced or if he stays on, and this weighs on his ratings, on the party’s ratings, it’s just going to make the ANC’s task in 2024 elections that much more difficult and I think the market will take a view that the fiscal risks will increase.”

Michael Kafe and Andreas Kolbe of Barclays Bank plc:

“Were Ramaphosa to offer to step aside, the ruling party would need to put forward a candidate – either the deputy president or a care-taker president.”We do not believe that Deputy President David Mabuza, who did not receive enough nominations for the upcoming ANC leadership contest on 16-20 December, will be put forward.”In our view, the party’s treasurer-general and acting secretary-general, Paul Mashatile, who currently has the most nominations for the post of deputy president for the December elective conference, will likely be put forward for the presidency.

“From a markets perspective, we believe that an early departure of President Ramaphosa will be perceived negatively, as the progress that he has made on reforms in the power sector and rebuilding of institutions will likely wane. Although Mr Mashatile has already indicated that his party would focus on the economy, as a priority, we believe that financial markets will take time to warm up to him.”

Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA) statement:

“BLSA has been dedicated to supporting the restoration of the rule of law in South Africa and that has been illustrated by the significant amount of resources and support that BLSA has spent in this regard.

“The Section 89 Independent Panel appointed by Parliament to investigate the conduct of President Cyril Ramaphosa has done its work without fear or favour.

“This is a positive sign of the health of our democracy and its institutions, and we welcome the report. We note its findings that the president may have violated certain parts of the constitution and a section of the Prevention and Combatting of Corrupt Activities Act.

“However, we see it as highly positive that the appropriate steps have been taken to investigate allegations. It is now important that our institutions are supported in concluding investigations and if appropriate further actions are taken to prosecute or otherwise impose appropriate consequences without fear or favour.

“We would also like to call on all the other organs of state who are working on this matter to conclude their processes and come forward with their findings.”

Listen to Fifi Peters speaking to Business Unity SA CEO Cas Coovadia about the impact of the Phala Phala report (or read the transcript here): 

Colin Coleman, former head of Goldman Sachs in sub-Saharan Africa:

“This finding most certainly throws the cat amongst the pigeons with respect to the December elective conference, and further imperils the prospects of both ANC renewal and meaningful economic, social and pro-democracy reforms. It is a victory for the regressive elements in the ANC.

“South African business will remain resilient, even if these developments will breathe oxygen into the crime and corruption networks the president was seeking to target. It will provide oxygen, in turn, to those who wish to see a new political alternative to the ANC rise out of the ashes in advance of 2024 national elections.”

Thabi Leoka, a Johannesburg-based economist:

“President Ramaphosa was seen as the president of hope and renewal. His recent trips to the White House, COP27 in Egypt the G-20 and Buckingham Palace saw him solidify relationships with world leaders whilst pushing for funding for the renewable energy transition and extending trade relations. The timing of a possible impeachment and the ushering in of a new ANC president puts all these efforts at a standstill.”

Peter Attard Montalto, head of capital markets research at Intellidex:

“We seem to have reached the end of the road of the president’s post-2017 contradictions and things will revert to type in some ways. Investors are going to need to get ready for what reopening the taps looks like. Analysts and ratings agencies dropped the ball in the Zuma years on blatant corruption till it was staring them in the face and that cannot happen again. Other policy areas may see less change – fiscal won’t suddenly dive off a cliff – and reforms and the need to solve energy and logistics won’t disappear but will get noisier and more complex.”

Lumkile Mondi, a senior economics lecturer at University of the Witwatersrand: 

“I don’t think much is going to change. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has been very clear about where South Africa needs to go and given the medium-term budget policy statement that he issued, it’s very, very clear where the course is heading to: We are consolidating, we are working very, very hard to mobilise global finance for our transition, we are engaged with institutions to help us overcome our energy insecurity.”

Kieran Curtis, director of investment at Abrdn:

“The report introduces much more uncertainty than investors were prepared for. Investors will basically want to know what happens next in parliament and in the elective conference: both are immediate challenges, the latter is the more likely I think to present a challenge to Ramaphosa.”

Listen to RMB’s John Cairns discussing the local currency’s moves as markets – and the nation – await Ramaphosa’s next move: 

© 2022 Bloomberg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *